South Milwaukee, WI
4 insurance agencies in South Milwaukee, Wisconsin, with Google ratings, hours and websites where the business has them.
Compare
Recommended businesses first, then businesses that have claimed their profile, then Verified ones, then by Google rating and review count. Use Sort to see highest rated first.
4 of 4 shown. Recommended businesses first, then businesses that have claimed their profile, then Verified ones, then by Google rating and review count. Use Sort to see highest rated first.
Top rated
Ranked by Google rating, then review count. Only businesses rated 4.5 or higher with 5+ Google reviews qualify.
5.0136 Google reviewsVerified
4.885 Google reviewsVerified
4.645 Google reviewsVerified
See every insurance agencies in South Milwaukee sorted by rating · Best of South Milwaukee across every trade
Request a consultation
Describe the job once, choose up to 10 claimed companies near you, and compare their quotes side by side. Your phone number stays private until you choose one. Free, no account, nobody pays to be on your list.
4 insurance agencies serve South Milwaukee, WI. 3 are rated 4.5 or higher on Google and 1 has a perfect 5.0. 4 have a website.
Sponsored
Up to 2 businesses can hold a sponsored spot in South Milwaukee, WI. A sponsored business sits above the regular results with a Sponsored tag; it never changes how other businesses are ranked.
Page One Partner Research
| Insurance Agencies | WI | U.S. |
|---|---|---|
| Average Google rating (10+ reviews) | 4.55 | 4.62 |
| Median Google reviews | 15 | 18 |
| Reviews for the top quarter | 65+ | 71+ |
| Have a website | 70.4% | 73.9% |
Businesses listed in our directory, not every business in the market. Updated September 2026. Insurance Agencies industry report · What is a good rating for insurance agencies? · Best cities for insurance agencies
From Page One Partner Research
Quick answers
Names and Google ratings, straight from each business's profile.
4 insurance agencies serve South Milwaukee, WI. Highest rated (10+ reviews): Brew City Insurance (Verified, rated 5.0 on Google from 136 reviews), Procter Insurance Agency (Verified, rated 4.8 on Google from 85 reviews) and Craig Baumeister - State Farm Insurance Agent (Verified, rated 4.6 on Google from 45 reviews), plus 1 more.
4 insurance agencies serve South Milwaukee, Wisconsin. 3 are rated 4.5 or higher on Google and 1 has a perfect 5.0. 4 have a website. ZIP codes covered: 53172.
Brew City Insurance (136 reviews, rated 5.0), Procter Insurance Agency (85 reviews, rated 4.8) and Craig Baumeister - State Farm Insurance Agent (45 reviews, rated 4.6). Review counts are read from each business's Google Business Profile.
FAQ
How businesses get here and how up to date everything is.
Find your South Milwaukee business and claim it free: correct details, add photos and services, and get quote requests sent straight to you.