Skip to content
Page One Partner

Middleton, WI

14 insurance agencies in Middleton, Wisconsin, with Google ratings, hours and websites where the business has them.

See all 14 with filters ↓

Compare

14 insurance agencies serving Middleton

Recommended businesses first, then businesses that have claimed their profile, then Verified ones, then by Google rating and review count. Use Sort to see highest rated first.

Filter

14 of 14 shown. Recommended businesses first, then businesses that have claimed their profile, then Verified ones, then by Google rating and review count. Use Sort to see highest rated first.

Top rated

Highest-rated insurance agencies in Middleton

Ranked by Google rating, then review count. Only businesses rated 4.5 or higher with 5+ Google reviews qualify.

  1. The Health Insurance Store

    5.0974 Google reviewsVerified

  2. Petersburg Insurance Agency LLC

    5.08 Google reviewsVerified

  3. Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent

    4.9121 Google reviewsVerified

  4. AVID Risk Solutions

    4.958 Google reviewsVerified

  5. Schwarz Insurance Agency

    4.938 Google reviewsVerified

  6. Baer Insurance Services Inc.

    4.774 Google reviewsVerified

See every insurance agencies in Middleton sorted by rating · Best of Middleton across every trade

Request a consultation

Ask up to three Middleton insurance agencies for a consultation

Describe the job once, choose up to 10 claimed companies near you, and compare their quotes side by side. Your phone number stays private until you choose one. Free, no account, nobody pays to be on your list.

Request a consultation in Middleton

14 insurance agencies serve Middleton, WI. 9 are rated 4.5 or higher on Google and 5 have a perfect 5.0. 12 have a website.

Verified on Google
7
Average rating
4.8 / 5
Google reviews
1,309

Sponsored

Advertise in Middleton, WI

Reserve a sponsored spot

Up to 2 businesses can hold a sponsored spot in Middleton, WI. A sponsored business sits above the regular results with a Sponsored tag; it never changes how other businesses are ranked.

More services in Middleton

All 45 services in Middleton

Page One Partner Research

How insurance agencies in Middleton compare

Insurance AgenciesMiddletonWIU.S.
Average Google rating (10+ reviews)4.84.554.62
Median Google reviews181518
Reviews for the top quarter66+65+71+
Have a website85.7%70.4%73.9%

Businesses listed in our directory, not every business in the market. Updated September 2026. Insurance Agencies industry report · What is a good rating for insurance agencies? · Best cities for insurance agencies

From Page One Partner Research

  • In Middleton, half of the insurance agencies we list with reviews have 18 or fewer Google reviews, and 66+ puts one in the local top quarter; the average rating is 4.8 (14 listed in our directory). Insurance Agencies industry report
  • A good Google rating for insurance agencies: in our directory, the median is 4.9 and at least a quarter hold a perfect 5.0. Half of them have 18 or fewer reviews. What is a good rating for insurance agencies?
  • Wisconsin businesses in our directory average 4.52 stars on Google, ranking 29 of the 50 states we measured; 26.6% list no website. Ratings in every state

Quick answers

Who serves Middleton?

Names and Google ratings, straight from each business's profile.

Which insurance agencies serve Middleton, WI?

14 insurance agencies serve Middleton, WI. Highest rated (10+ reviews): The Health Insurance Store (Verified, rated 5.0 on Google from 974 reviews), Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent (Verified, rated 4.9 on Google from 121 reviews) and AVID Risk Solutions (Verified, rated 4.9 on Google from 58 reviews), plus 11 more.

How many insurance agencies serve Middleton, WI, and how are they rated?

14 insurance agencies serve Middleton, Wisconsin. 9 are rated 4.5 or higher on Google and 5 have a perfect 5.0. 12 have a website. ZIP codes covered: 53562.

Which insurance agencies in Middleton, WI have the most Google reviews?

The Health Insurance Store (974 reviews, rated 5.0), Aaron Achenbach - State Farm Insurance Agent (121 reviews, rated 4.9) and Baer Insurance Services Inc. (74 reviews, rated 4.7). Review counts are read from each business's Google Business Profile.

Insurance Agencies near Middleton

All of Wisconsin · Cities A–Z

FAQ

Questions about Middleton businesses

How businesses get here and how up to date everything is.

Yes. Page One Partner is a free directory of local service businesses across the United States. It costs nothing to search, and nothing for a business to be listed. Each profile is built from the business's public Google Business Profile, and an owner can claim, update or hide theirs at any time by contacting info@pageoneinsights.com.

Run a business in Middleton, WI?

Find your Middleton business and claim it free: correct details, add photos and services, and get quote requests sent straight to you.

Find your business +1 (888) 272-1940